Merch

DIY Fan Goods and Copyright: Separating Color Craft, Official Art, and Sharing

Spending time assembling a cheering uchiwa fan, a rosette, or a beaded strap inspired by your oshi (your favorite idol or character) with your own hands brings the hands-on joy of experimenting with combinations of colors and materials. At the same time, the moment you think about incorporating official illustrations, photos, or logos—or posting your finished piece on social media or handing it out to friends—you may find yourself wondering where the territory that requires checking copyright and usage rules begins.

An illustration of crafting handmade cheering uchiwa fans and fan goods

Sorting out the rights surrounding DIY fan goods becomes much clearer when you stop looking for a single blanket standard based on whether something is “handmade,” and instead separate two questions: what elements you use to make it (the subject matter) and who makes it and how far outside the home it goes (the act). Choosing colors and materials through your own creative ingenuity differs in nature from reproducing an official copyrighted work, and enjoying something privately in your own hands operates under different premises than publishing, distributing, or selling it to the outside world.

Please note that this article organizes general ways of thinking based on publicly available institutional explanations and examples of official guidelines; it does not judge the legality of any individual creation. To determine what is permissible in a specific case, please check the guidance provided by the rights holder or consult a legal professional such as an attorney.

Separating Crafting Ingenuity from the Use of Specific Expressions

In handmade fan goods, the “ideas for colors, materials, and layout” chosen by the maker often mingle with the “official images, character art, logos, and names” specific to a work or franchise.

The reason we need to separate these two from the very start is that copyright law protects different things. In the Agency for Cultural Affairs’ overview of the copyright system (in Japanese), it is explained that mere facts, data, ideas, and commonplace expressions do not constitute copyrighted works. Elements that do not qualify as copyrighted works can be used without permission from a copyright holder.

For instance, tasks like “selecting blue and white ribbons in your oshi’s member colors and weaving them together with store-bought lace to make a rosette for an ita-bag (a bag decorated with fan badges and goods)” or “cutting out lettering for a cheering message you wrote yourself” are acts of giving form to color-scheme and crafting ideas. Choosing colors themselves or general decorative ideas is not treated the same way as directly copying and pasting an officially released character illustration or a photograph of an artist.

That said, because where protected creative expression begins depends on each individual design and combination, we cannot treat this like a rigid checklist and assume that “anything hand-drawn is completely free to use” or “as long as it is only colors, any kind of use is fine.” Conversely, there is no need to hold back excessively out of fear that merely using a color associated with your oshi is immediately illegal. The starting point is to distinguish whether your craft project is a “combination of colors and materials” or a “use of specific official art, photos, or logos.”

The Boundary Between Using It Yourself and Sharing or Ordering Externally

The next distinction to check—whenever your project involves copyrighted works such as official illustrations or photographs—is the difference in the act itself: within what scope you make the item, and how you handle it.

On the Agency for Cultural Affairs’ explanatory page (in Japanese), copyright is positioned as a framework built for both creators and users, with statutory exceptions such as “private use” within a limited scope like personal or household enjoyment. At the same time, checking rights when publishing content on the internet or creating derivative works (nijisousaku, fan-made secondary creations) must be considered separately from private use.

When we apply this to making DIY fan goods, the decision points shift step by step as follows.

DIAGRAMVerification Steps from Making to Using DIY Fan Goods
  1. 1. Check the Elements You Want to UseCheck whether you are using colors, materials, and general parts chosen yourself, or including official art, photos, logos, and character expressions.
  2. 2. Check Production Method and Scope of UseSeparate personal or household enjoyment from posting on social media, handing out to friends, selling on flea market apps, or ordering from outside vendors.
  3. 3. Cross-Check Official GuidelinesBeyond the target IP's general rules, read additional conditions for 3D items and goods as well as prohibited acts (such as direct copying or corporate use).
  4. 4. How to Respond When UnsureIf rules are unpublished or your plan falls outside their conditions, avoid borrowing official expressions and switch to crafting centered on colors and materials.

Source: The Oshi Lab's summary of the article

A particularly common point of confusion along this path is the assumption that “as long as I don’t charge money (if it’s non-profit), I don’t need permission for anything,” or that “handing things out to friends or social media followers still counts as private use.” As the Agency for Cultural Affairs explains, there is no general rule that non-profit use automatically removes the need for permission. Private use within a household rests on different legal premises than uploading images to social media for an unspecified large audience to see, or handing out and distributing items to others at events or concert venues.

Furthermore, when using generative AI as a production tool or copying and arranging official illustrations by hand, there is no special exemption where “running it through AI means no rights check is needed” or “doing it by hand makes it a completely separate work.” Whenever you incorporate existing creative expressions and publish or distribute the result, the procedure of checking the conditions set by the rights holder remains the same.

How to Read Official Guidelines: The Example of hololive production

When individuals or doujin circles (independent fan creator groups) produce, publish, or distribute fan art and derivative merchandise, the practical roadmap they rely on is the set of guidelines published by each rights holder. Guidance from the Agency for Cultural Affairs likewise notes that when rights holders publish usage rules, reading their scope and conditions is the fundamental first step.

What requires careful attention here is that guidelines contain not only an “overall basic policy,” but also detailed conditions broken down by the “type of item” and the “presence or absence of creative originality.” As a concrete example, let us look at the hololive production Derivative Works Guidelines (in Japanese) (an example of rules aimed at activities within Japan), published by COVER Corp.

While expressing a supportive stance toward fan creative activities, these guidelines organize the conditions fans must follow across multiple layers.

The first layer is the distinction between “derivative works with creative ingenuity” and “direct use or mere alteration of official content.” Works to which fans have added their own creative originality fall under the derivative work guidelines, whereas acts such as directly copying official illustrations, videos, or logos—or making alterations that lack creativity, such as simply changing the colors or cropping an image—are not considered derivative works and are not covered by the general guidelines. It is important to note that merchandise made by simply printing official images as-is is not permitted under these guidelines.

The second layer is the line drawn between “the scope of hobby and doujin activities” and “commercial or corporate use.” The guidelines apply to hobby-level activities by individuals or doujin circles, and state that use by corporations—which the company regards as commercial in purpose—is refused in principle. In doing so, the guidelines lay out a specific standard: even if an application or production is made under an individual’s name, cases where a corporation bears the expenses are regarded as corporate (commercial) use and are refused in principle.

The third layer consists of additional conditions regarding three-dimensional and sculpted objects. The general guidelines alone do not exempt every kind of merchandise production; displaying, distributing, selling or accepting reservations for figures and garage kits requires following applicable event, platform and authorization rules. In addition to the general guidelines, separate category-specific guidelines are set for areas like music and games, and additional guidance may also exist for activities conducted outside Japan.

DIAGRAMComparing Easily Confused Decisions in DIY and Derivative Works

Self-Devised Crafting and Household Use

  • Selecting and coordinating store-bought ribbons or beads to match an oshi's image color
  • Making small accessories by combining mere facts, ideas, and commonplace expressions
  • Verifying that even personal or household use satisfies the legal requirements for private use

Uses Requiring Official Guideline or Permission Checks

  • Reproducing or altering specific creative expressions such as official illustrations, photos, or logos
  • Publishing finished works on social media, or distributing and selling them to others at events or online
  • Displaying, distributing, selling or accepting reservations for sculpted items like figures (checking applicable event, platform and authorization rules)

Source: The Oshi Lab's summary of the article

As this shows, even looking at a single company’s guidelines, things cannot be summed up in a single phrase like “derivative works are OK.” Instead, you need to read through the conditions in order: Is this a direct use of official assets? Does it stay within the scope of a hobby? Are there separate provisions for sculpted items? Moreover, these represent the current conditions specific to hololive production, not a universal rule shared by all anime, idol, and game companies. Because some companies have not issued guidelines at all and some intellectual properties (IPs) prohibit fan-made merchandise across the board, checking primary sources for the specific genre or franchise before you start making anything is indispensable.

By Scenario: Preparation and Decisions Fans Can Try Before Crafting

How, then, should fans think through the steps when planning DIY fan goods so they can begin working with peace of mind? Below, we organize practical ways to approach the decision across three common scenarios.

1. Cheering Uchiwa Fans and Rosettes to Bring to Concerts and Event Venues

This is the scenario where you make an uchiwa fan, a name board, or a rosette to hold yourself at a venue. Here, the most reliable approach—and the one that gives you the greatest creative freedom—is to complete your design using colored paper, ribbons, and lettering layouts chosen with your own hands, without using cutouts of official photos or logos.

By focusing on font choices, color-scheme ingenuity, and combinations of store-bought decorative parts, you can express your support for your oshi without reproducing official copyrighted works. If you do want to incorporate elements of an official character, decide beforehand whether the item will remain strictly within the scope of personal or household enjoyment, or whether you plan to post work-in-progress or finished photos on social media or hand items out to friends at the venue. If you plan to share or take it outside that private scope, avoid pasting official images directly and check to what extent the target IP’s guidelines permit publishing fan art.

2. Gifts for Friends and Trading or Handing Out Items at Events

This is the scenario where you want to hand out handmade keychains or stickers to friends you meet at a venue, or give items away for free as a small gift. Even when no money changes hands, handing items out to others beyond the scope of your household operates under different conditions than making something solely for your own use.

Scanning or printing official illustrations or logos to hand out should be avoided, as it easily runs afoul of guideline restrictions against “direct use lacking creativity.” If you want to enjoy giving gifts or trading items, the safe procedure is either to make beaded accessories or oshi-color (signature character or member color) crafts that do not use official assets, or—for an IP whose derivative work guidelines explicitly permit hobby- and doujin-scale distribution—to create items using an illustration you drew from scratch while staying strictly within the stated conditions (such as limits on eligible item types, quantities, and venues).

3. Making Acrylic Stands or 3D Items and Ordering from Outside Vendors

This is the scenario where you want to turn fan art you drew yourself into an acrylic stand, or sculpt a three-dimensional character figure out of clay or resin. This area calls for the most careful verification.

Whenever you submit digital files to an outside print shop or merchandise manufacturer, or distribute finished items, always check how each IP’s guidelines define the handling of merchandise production and three-dimensional objects. As seen in the hololive production example above, even when publishing an illustration falls within the general guidelines, displaying, distributing, selling or accepting reservations for figures and garage kits is subject to separate authorization rules. Before placing an order, read both the rights holder’s terms and the submission policy of the print shop you plan to use.

Rights Holders and Production Services Should Clarify Scope and Eligible Items

On the other side of the relationship, when rights holders and custom-printing services prepare guidance for users, it is important to clearly separate cases where official assets are used as-is from cases where fans add their own creative ingenuity. At the same time, making it easy for users to navigate to additional conditions by item type—such as image posts, doujinshi (self-published fan books), merchandise, and sculpted objects—helps creators locate the rules relevant to their specific activity.

Conditions for cases involving corporations or activities conducted overseas should also be communicated in clear correspondence with the basic rules. Including operational policies—such as whether an inquiry desk is available to accept individual questions, or whether the published guideline text serves in place of individual replies—makes the verification process clear for everyone.

The joy of experimenting with colors and materials to make something by hand and the commitment to respecting a work’s creative expressions can go hand in hand. Before you start crafting, decide which elements you will use and how far your creation will be shared, and read the applicable official rules before bringing your project to life.

Related articles: What Are Derivative Works (Nijisousaku)? (Glossary) / What Is Fan Art? / What Is a Cheering Uchiwa Fan? / Storage Ideas for Oshi Goods

FAQ

If I print an official photo to make a cheering uchiwa fan, how far does personal use go?

According to the Agency for Cultural Affairs' explanation, private use as a legal exception to copyright covers use within a limited scope, such as by yourself or within your home. Because the underlying conditions differ between making an item to use yourself at home and posting it on social media, distributing or selling it to third parties, or placing an order with an outside vendor, you need to check each action separately.

Do I need official permission to make my own rosettes or small accessories by choosing ribbons and beads in my oshi's image color?

According to the Agency for Cultural Affairs' overview of the copyright system, mere facts, ideas, and commonplace expressions do not qualify as copyrighted works. Using your own ingenuity to choose colors and combine color schemes or materials is not treated the same way as directly reproducing specific creative expressions such as official character illustrations, photos, or logos.

Is permission unnecessary if I hand items out to friends for free or distribute them only for the actual cost of materials with no profit?

There is no general rule that permission is never needed as long as an activity is non-profit or free of charge. Whenever you go beyond the scope of private use enjoyed by yourself or within your household—such as handing items out or distributing them to others, or posting them online—you need to check the conditions in the guidelines published by the work or rights holder in question.

If official derivative work guidelines are published, can I freely make and distribute acrylic stands or figures?

Even when general guidelines exist, separate conditions may be set for three-dimensional objects and merchandise. For example, hololive production's general derivative work guidelines are premised on hobby and doujin (self-published fan) activities, while also stipulating that displaying, distributing, selling or accepting reservations for figures and garage kits requires following the applicable authorization rules.

If I use an illustration I drew by hand or an image generated by AI, is there no need to check rights?

Regardless of the production method—whether hand-drawn or AI-generated—checking rights and official guidelines is essential whenever your work is based on existing characters or official expressions. Some guidelines, such as those of hololive production, draw a clear distinction between derivative works that add creative ingenuity and the direct use of official content or mere alterations lacking creativity.